First off, I am a gamer not a POTC Fan. I find that though fun, all you need is one combo( one that breaks through defenses) and you're ranged weapons. I once went through a entire level not using my sword( which is sad). Still I did feel powerful and am proud to have beaten the game with 8 or so hrs. While fun, replay value is extremely low. And I would recommend a rent or get used and play within the 1 week and then return it.